F-35 Lightning II vs Dassault Rafale

The F-35 compared with other modern jets.
  • Author
  • Message
Offline

Corsair1963

Elite 5K

Elite 5K

  • Posts: 7546
  • Joined: 19 Dec 2005, 04:14

Unread post09 Jun 2021, 06:09

Dassault Rafale in good position to win Switzerland tender?

As the decision on the next fighter jet to fly with the colors of the Swiss Air Force is about to be made, local media reports that the scales might be tilted in favor of the Dassault Rafale.

The Air 2030 tender was launched in 2020 following the positive outcome of a referendum on whether Switzerland should acquire or not new fighter jets. 50.1% of voters have voted “yes” to the procurement of new aircraft for the Swiss Air Force.

https://www.aerotime.aero/28110-dassaul ... and-tender



Swiss leaning toward Rafale jet purchase: report

Swiss order will replace the McDonnell Douglas F/A-18C/D Hornets and the remaining Northrop F-5E/F Tigers

by Dave Makichuk
June 9, 2021

After securing major contracts in Greece, Croatia, India and Egypt, French aeronautics firm Dassault Aviation is close to inking a major deal with Switzerland for the Rafale fighter jet, according to local media reports.

The Air 2030 tender for the Swiss Air Force was launched in 2020 following the positive outcome of a referendum on whether Switzerland should acquire new fighter jets.

According to AerotimeHub, 50.1% of voters have voted “yes” to the procurement estimated at 6 billion Swiss francs (roughly US$7 billion). The acquisition would concern 30 to 40 aircraft to be delivered by 2025.

The choice of the model of the new combat aircraft by the Federal Council could be made before the end of June 2021. If Switzerland was to pick the Rafale, it would mark yet another success for the French fighter jet.

The Rafale is still competing in Finland and is also being considered by Ukraine and Indonesia.


The Swiss order aims to replace the McDonnell Douglas F/A-18C/D Hornets and the few remaining Northrop F-5E/F Tiger II antiques that are still assigned to secondary tasks.

The main purpose of the upcoming multi-role fighter jet will be to carry out air policing missions.

Four contenders are currently in the race: the Dassault Rafale, the Lockheed Martin F-35, the Boeing F/A-18 Super Hornet, and the Eurofighter Typhoon. The Saab Gripen E/F was excluded as it will not be operational before 2023.

Six foreign customers are procuring and operating the F-35 — Israel, Japan, South Korea, Poland, Belgium and Singapore.

Lockheed Martin serves as the prime contractor with a global supply chain of more than 1,900 companies based in the US and in every nation acquiring the F-35 — a tempting consideration for governments trying to foster high-tech job creation.

However, the odds could be in favor of the French offer, according to Le Matin.

The first indication is that a US-based solution would be politically unwise.

The Swiss politicians who had initially campaigned against the procurement later voiced their opposition to the Boeing F-18, and even more so to the Lockheed Martin F-35.

“Buying the American F-35s, which are the most expensive, is excluded,” said Roger Nordmann, the leader of the Socialist group in the Federal Assembly.

The second element presented by Le Matin is that the Federal Office of Armaments (Amasuisse) recently acquired from the French manufacturer Thales the aerial surveillance system SkyView.

“Even if it is not compulsory, there would be consistency between a surveillance system of French origin and French planes,” the daily states.

The final argument, though slightly more anecdotal, is that the Rafale was the only aircraft highlighted by Priska Seiler Graf, a member of the Security Policy Commission which will decide on the fighter jet, in a question regarding the operational range of the Swiss Armed Forces.

For years, Croatia has been in the process of modernizing its air force by replacing older Soviet-era aircraft with both new and secondhand aircraft.

On May 28, the nation took a major leap forward by selecting the Dassault Rafale F3-R for its air force, following an international call for tenders as part of its Multi-Role Fighter Aircraft program.

Croatia is acquiring 12 second-hand aircraft from the French Air Force in a deal worth €999 million (US$1.2 billion). France is to deliver the first six aircraft in 2024, with the remainder following in 2025.


In addition to the aircraft, the deal also includes a flight simulator, basic weapons package, ground and test equipment, spare parts, staff training according to the principle of “training of trainers,” comprehensive support from authorized representatives of manufacturers for a period of three years, and a warranty of 12 months for each delivered aircraft, engines, other equipment, and spare parts.

Meanwhile, the Finnish Government will decide which of the companies’ fighters to purchase by the end of 2021.

The program is expected to cost €10 billion with requirements including not only the aircraft but also ‘technical systems, training systems, necessary maintenance equipment, test equipment and spare parts, along with weapons, sensors’ and other support equipment.

According to the Dassault website, The Rafale is a twin-jet fighter aircraft able to operate from both an aircraft carrier and a shore base.

The US$115 million jet fighter is able to carry out various combat aviation missions: air superiority and air defense, close air support, in-depth strikes, reconnaissance, anti-ship strikes and nuclear deterrence.

The Rafale entered service with the French Navy in 2004 and with the French Air Force in 2006. With more than 30,000 flight hours in operations, it has proven its worth in combat in Afghanistan, Libya, Mali, Iraq and Syria, the company said.

https://asiatimes.com/2021/06/swiss-lea ... se-report/
Offline

hornetfinn

Elite 3K

Elite 3K

  • Posts: 3564
  • Joined: 13 Mar 2013, 08:31
  • Location: Finland

Unread post09 Jun 2021, 11:18

I think that article in "Le Matin" is reading way too much into these things. I don't think acquiring Thales SkyView favours Rafale at all. Internal politics might favor Rafale somewhat, but I don't know enough about Swiss politics to really know that.

Another article with some interesting info:
https://www.forbes.com/sites/erictegler ... ar-choice/

“We’re in a great position … We’re going to come in at or below the cost of the 4th generation competitors so I think that makes us really competitive,” Robinson says.

He stresses that Lockheed’s proposal includes 40 aircraft (rather than the 36 reported) with significant industrial offset, priced within the $6.5 billion budget. He adds that unlike its competitors, the F-35 will not require the Swiss to buy additional accessories like launch rails, targeting pods or special weapons interfaces, all of which are integrated within the F-35A.

“The aircraft is ready on day one. You don’t need additional mission equipment to add capability to the aircraft,” Robinson says.

The Lightning II is also headed in the right direction in terms of volume, support and cost per flight hour (CPFH), Lockheed’s campaign manager asserts.



But Robinson maintains that the F-35’s sophistication makes it the only candidate viable in a broader air defense.

“In their Air 2030 upgrade program they are looking for a combined defensive air network. The F-35 in its quarterbacking role can provide valuable data as they look to upgrade their ground-based air defense systems.”

One might also question the value of stealth. As a former USAF F-16 pilot, Robinson says that he “would have loved to be sure the offensive air didn’t know where I was in my defensive counter-air role.”


In Lockheed’s case the sweeteners include the opportunity to produce about 400 canopies and transparencies (the canopy frame and glass) for the F-35 domestically. Switzerland would be the European hub for such work and take on unspecified engine and airframe sustainment projects for its own operations and possibly others.
Offline
User avatar

steve2267

Elite 2K

Elite 2K

  • Posts: 2793
  • Joined: 12 Jun 2016, 17:36

Unread post10 Jun 2021, 01:46

On technical merits and costs, the Swiss competition would appear to be a slam dunk for the F-35. BUT... the US was rather hard on the Swiss banking system in the past decade or so. That may tilt the intangible political factor against American competitors. With the neighboring Austrians apparently souring on the Typhoon in a big way, I think the Eurofighter is a long shot. Boing who? I think the Super Duper is pretty much forgotten. I would not be surprised if the Swiss opt for the Rafale. It's a decent jet. And I'd say good on the French.

If the primary role is really going to be air policing, then the Swiss coulda just bought whatever off the shelf. An armed BAE Hawk or Korean FA-50 is probably plenty. Or a Boing T-7 with missiles. But if the Swiss are serious, truly serious, about defending their nation, then IMO I don't see how you do not buy the F-35. Especially as LM has managed to bring down the purchase price, and, foreign nations especially, the cost of operations does not seem out of line.

Circling back around to the political intangibles that seem to weight against a LM win... I note that ULA, the 50-50 Boing / LM launch vehicle provider, has a pretty big manufacturing deal with the Swiss company Ruag for the production of composite payload fairings for both the Atlas V and forthcoming Vulcan Centaur rockets. So perhaps LM is in a better situation behind the scenes? Dunno.
Take an F-16, stir in A-7, dollop of F-117, gob of F-22, dash of F/A-18, sprinkle with AV-8B, stir well + bake. Whaddya get? F-35.
Offline

magitsu

Forum Veteran

Forum Veteran

  • Posts: 844
  • Joined: 12 Jun 2015, 22:12

Unread post10 Jun 2021, 13:20

It seems an initial contract for 36 Rafale to Indonesia has been signed on Monday.

Indonesia signed initial contract for the procurement of 36 @Dassault_OnAir Rafale omni-role fighters, says Angkasa Review website, a firm contract is still far away though

https://twitter.com/marhalimabas/status ... 5431045122

Good news, the Ministry of Defense and Dassault have signed the initial 36 Rafale contracts
June 10, 2021

AIRSPACE REVIEW (airspace-review.com) – Good news from the planned purchase of defense equipment by the Ministry of Defense of the Republic of Indonesia (Kemhan RI).

An Airspace Review source in Jakarta said the Indonesian Ministry of Defense and Dassault Aviation (the manufacturer of the Rafale ) from France had signed an initial contract for the procurement of 36 multi-role fighter jets.

The signing of the initial contract called the “Come Into Force” contract was signed on Monday, June 7, 2021 and will take effect in December 2021.

“The 'Come Into Force' contract was signed on Monday, June 7th. The contract will go into effect in December this year," said an AR source.

He added that Indonesia's journey to get the Rafale plane from France is still long.

The “Come Into Force” contract will then become the basis for the Effective Contract after all agreements between Indonesia and France are reached and Indonesia has paid an advance for the purchase of 36 Rafales.
Meanwhile, until now Indonesia and France have not reached agreement points for Trade Returns, Local Content and/or Offsets (IDKLO) in terms of the planned purchase of 36 Rafale.

As is known, Law no. 16 of 2012 concerning the Defense Industry mandates that the purchase of alpalhankam (defense and security equipment) from abroad must be accompanied by an IDKLO.

The plan to purchase Rafale fighter jets surfaced after the French daily, La Tribune, reported the intention of the Indonesian Minister of Defense Prabowo Subianto to buy this aircraft.

Prabowo met with the Minister of the French Armed Forces Florence Parly during a working visit in Paris, France on October 21, 2020.

In December 2020, La Tribune reported that Indonesia would buy 48 Rafale units from France.

Later, various reports stated that Indonesia would buy 36 Rafales from the Eiffel Tower country, not 48 as the initial reports.

Dassault has held a meeting with the Indonesian Ministry of Defense in Jakarta on February 21, 2021.

The Dassault team consists of Vice President of Dassault Aviation Business Development Jean Claude Piccharillo and Vice President of Offset Dassault Michael Paskoff.

Their arrival was received by the Director General of Defense Potential (Ditjen Pothan) of the Ministry of Defense Maj. Gen. Dadang Hendrayudha and the Director of Defense Industrial Technology (Dirtekindhan) Laksma TNI Sri Yanto.

https://www.airspace-review.com/2021/06 ... 36-rafale/

Previous 19 May La Tribune article:
Indonesia very, very close to boarding the Rafale

The contract for the acquisition of Rafale awaits a presidential decree, which will make it possible to supplement budget lines from the Ministry of Defense to finance this purchase.

However, the [Indonesian MoD Prabowo Subianto] minister still has to wait for a presidential decree from Joko Widodo decisive to abound budget lines for the benefit of the Ministry of Defense and thus ensure the financing of the contract before it can be made effective. According to a source familiar with the matter, the Indonesian Defense Minister is expected to meet in "the next few weeks" his counterpart, Florence Parly, who had mentioned in December an order for 36 Rafale by Jakarta. The CEO of Dassault Aviation Eric Trappier mentioned last January an order of between 24 and forty fighters.

The industrial proposal and the contractualization have been made. The French industrialists (GIE Rafale) had submitted their initial offer in December. The ball is therefore in Joko Widodo's camp and everyone is now waiting for the authorization to engage, which must be given by the Indonesian president.

https://www.latribune.fr/entreprises-fi ... 84904.html
Offline

herciv

Active Member

Active Member

  • Posts: 159
  • Joined: 04 May 2016, 08:24

Unread post10 Jun 2021, 13:57

magitsu wrote:It seems an initial contract for 36 Rafale to Indonesia has been signed on Monday.

Indonesia signed initial contract for the procurement of 36 @Dassault_OnAir Rafale omni-role fighters, says Angkasa Review website, a firm contract is still far away though

Thank you for the link.
That's need to be confirmed since there are no news about it in France
Previous

Return to F-35 versus XYZ

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 20 guests